Critique Pit/CnC/C4C

So, I noticed in several forums there are CnC "Pits" if you will, in which in-depth no-emotion critiques are given. The goal is to give a good, down-to-earth review there. Insulting/rude feedback is discouraged, of course, but if you've got a point, say it. The goal is to improve each-other's work. Anyhow, I figured one of these might be useful. anyone agree?

- 3D

I disagree.

If they can't appreciate any type of criticism then there really isn't much point in posting if they can't handle the unexpected. Criticism should be appreciated by applying those mistakes into their next piece(s) for improvement.

Not needed. Just post it in showoff and say you want in-depth / down-to-earth critique. No need for a separate forum.

At least, that's what I think.